Review of ‘Captain Marvel’ (2018) Issue #4: Carol and Rogue Throw Down

Carol and Rogue fight, cover

If you’re a Carol Danvers nerd (hi) you know that Carol and Rogue go way back. At one point, Rogue drained Carol’s powers and personality, leaving her near death. Carol’s memories were restored by Professor Xavier, but she had no emotional attachment to them. Her personality, meanwhile, resided in Rogue’s head for a long time and nearly drove Rogue crazy. Good times, good times. They’re both pretty traumatized by the whole mess.

The history of Rogue and Carol

Which is why having the two of them throw down in Captain Marvel’s fourth issue had me bracing for impact.

Writer: Kelly Thompson
Artist: Carmen Carnero
Colorist: Tamra Bonvillain
Cover Artists: Amanda Conner & Paul Mounts

Related Post

There’s no pulling punches here (I’m sorry, I can’t stop myself); Carol is dealing with her trauma as she and Rogue fight, especially once she realizes that the only way to stop Nuclear Man is to let Rogue absorb her entirely, then take over Rogue’s body. She makes Rogue promise to let her go back once the fight is over. She’s terrified, and it’s conveyed through every single way that comics can: every layout, every facial expression, every line of dialogue is picture-perfect, the exact moment needed to convey the depths of revisiting this trauma. This is how they can win the war—by pushing past her terror and getting to the steel of her resolve.

Carol relives the trauma of Rogue taking her powers and personality

I really loved this issue. Hazmat’s mask has been exchanged for a clear one, meaning Echo can read her lips. The looks between Jess and Jen as they worry about Carol? Gorgeous. The fear on Carol’s face as Rogue drains her powers? Priceless. The artist and colorist did some exquisite work showing the energy transfer between the two characters; it’s clear but never overwhelming. I love it, from the dramatic moments to the small details.

And if you’re just turning up because the Captain Marvel movie was badass, this series is a great jumping on point for the character. The first page even gives you a quick recap of the Rogue and Carol’s history together, so that you’re not confused why these two fighting is a problem. The final image of a merged Rogue and Carol is one that will stick with you—especially as their lady team shows up, ready to fight Nuclear Man and his army.

A merged Carol and Rogue survey the battlefield

With the way Marvel is running arcs, issue #5 should wrap this one up. The pacing has been excellent; too often, books have that “wait, I have one more issue?!?!” feeling as they creep towards what is going to be a conclusion of sorts. This time, I feel like the smaller plot issues have been resolved, and we’re now ready for a battle of epic proportions.

I’m so ready.

Liked it? Take a second to support GeekMom and GeekDad on Patreon!

This post was last modified on May 9, 2019 11:30 am

K. Tilden Frost

K. Tilden Frost (Kay) is a full-time writer published in both fiction and non-fiction genres and fields. She is a geek for comics, autism advocacy, and parenting. She often works and writes with Mathias DeRider at GeekDad and ReviewOrDie.

Published by

Recent Posts

Make/Play/Watch/Read: Sign Languages

September 23 is International Day of Sign Languages, a day to celebrate the importance of…

September 17, 2021

GeekDad: ‘Gravwell 2nd Edition’: Bigger and (Mostly) Better

You’ve survived the black hole, but your engines are dead and you’re drifting in space.…

September 17, 2021

GeekDad: Review- ‘Hellboy and the B.P.R.D.: 1957’- Family Ties

‘Hellboy and the B.P.R.D.: 1957’ Writer: Mike Mignola, Chris Roberson Artist: Laurence Campbell Letterer: Clem…

September 17, 2021

GeekDad: GeekDad Daily Deal: The Ultimate Arduino Coding Power Course Bundle

Learn the ins-and-outs of coding for one of the most popular hobby computers out there.…

September 15, 2021

Audiobooks I Listened to While Going Through TMS Treatments for Mental Illness

GeekMom Dakster talks about all the books they listened to while undergoing TMS treatments for…

September 14, 2021

GeekDad: Stack Overflow: Tales of Disaster

Today’s stack is disastrous: these are all tales of catastrophe, some caused by people and…

September 14, 2021